Contemporary relationships between men and women are a whole world apart from the traditional relationships of our parents, where gender roles were clearly defined and it was unheard of for a man to talk about his feelings and emotions.
Before the gay and feminist movements of the 60’s and 70’s heterosexual men seldom talked about their emotions for fear of being called a ‘Puff’ or a ‘Jessie’. Thankfully, we have moved on from such narrow minded views and today’s men are much more willing to unload their emotional baggage.
However, sexual equality and male emotional expression has brought about fresh challenges for both sexes. An increasing number of men are experiencing an ‘identity crisis’ and women are faced with learning how to handle the emotional baggage of their partners.
Headlines such as, ‘Death of the Dad’, may cause some men to question their role and necessity in relationships. Due to the advancements in fertility treatment and the accepted fact that same sex relationships can offer the same stability and support for the healthy development of children, the traditional role of men has been brought in to question. Does this mean that Darwin’s Theory of Evolution, “survival of the fittest’ will see the penis being made redundant to fertility treatment?
Any counsellor, coach or therapist worth their weight in gold will tell you that one of the most powerful tools they have is the ability to listen without judgement and have unconditional regard for the needs of their clients. Advice for lasting relationships doesn’t necessarily need to be any more complicated than this. Effective listening is an essential skill for women to be able to handle the emotions of their partner.
We all know how respected women are for their ability to listen empathetically and yet sometimes we can still find ourselves slipping in to our default positions of being critical or ambivalent when seeking to understand our partner’s issues.
These are two simple and yet useful understandings for effectively listening and communicating, which will support you, support his emotional baggage.
Parent and Child; Listening as an Adult
Transactional analysis helps us to realize that during moments of emotional stress both your partner and you can default in to particular ‘ego states’; parent, child or adult. ‘Ego states’ affect how we think, feel and behave and consequently may influence how you listen and communicate their emotional issues. Becoming the caring and concerned partner (nurturing parent) can bring out the adaptive child in him, and potentially result in them being needier of you or even affecting his self esteem.
The parent in you
Interacting from the position of parent can result in you being either critical (controlling) or caring and concerned (nurturing) towards his emotional needs. Most will agree that being critical is seldom of any use, and I say, ‘seldom’ because there is a therapy called ‘provocative therapy’, yet I recommend that you avoid being critical at all costs.
We also need to be mindful of the fact that nurturing our partners emotional needs can sometimes be unhelpful, particularly when our care and concern results [with the best intention] in us offering solutions and advice. This can have the undesired effect of bringing out the ‘child’ in them and result in your partner becoming needier of you.
As a coach I never offer advice or solutions to a client, as this would not be respecting, recognising or reassuring them of my faith in their ability to find the solution to their issues themselves. It is important to always allow your partner to retain as much ownership for identifying his own solutions.
Listening as an adult
The most resourceful, supportive and caring ‘ego state’ any partner can adopt is generally that of an adult. This is the grown up rational person in you and who demonstrates the greatest level of support, respect and recognition of your partner’s abilities, by listening and talking with them with rational and reason. This allows them to feel cared for and take ownership for finding the solutions for themselves.
The Power of Questions
Just as some say that the ‘pen is mightier than the sword’, so to are questions mightier than answers. Listening hard and asking questions rather than providing what you feel is the answer to his issues is a very powerful source of support. This stems form something known as ‘Socratic Dialogue’, and by asking reasoned and rational questions, you enable your partner to reflect and think independently and critically about their own actions and choices until they arrive at the solution.
Top Tips
- Resist the temptation to offer advice or solutions
- Listen and the listen some more
- Listen without judgement
- Recognise that the solution to everything is within the individual
- Questions are more powerful than answers
- Ask questions that encourage them to reflect on their own thoughts and interpretations of an issue. Questions such as;
- How can you be sure of that?
- What else might it mean?
- What would (someone they vale and respect) do?
- What would you like to happen?
- How would you feel if?
- How could things be different?
- What do you need?
A Different Perspective
No matter how hard we listen and seek to support the emotional needs of our partner, it can sometimes become a bit of a challenge when we are stuck in see things from just our own point of view. We become a much greater source of support for our partners when we are able to see things differently by adopting a fresh perspective. This simple technique is great to allow yourself to see things differently, gain some clarity and appreciate things from your partner’s point of view.
Step 1 – the adult you
Ensure you are in the Adult ‘ego state’ and are thinking, listening and behaving with a reasoned and rational head.
Step 2 – your own point of view
Consider things from your own point of view. How do you feel about their issues and concerns? What do you feel is important to them? What do you see as their needs and to what extent do you feel they are they being met? How might you be hindering or helping them? How are they making you feel? What do you need to change in your approach to handling their emotions?
Step 3 – their point of view
Put yourself in your partner’s shoes and as your partner ask what you think about them (you)? How is your partner (you) coming across to you (remember you are asking yourself these questions as if you are them). To what extent do they (you) understand me? How do you feel about what they are saying? What would you like from them (you)? What could they (you) say that would be really helpful?
Step 4 – third party perspective
Allow yourself to become a detached observe and place yourself in the shoes of a stranger, observing you supporting your partner in order to consider the wider picture. As a stranger, ask yourself what these two people (you and your partner) are verbally and non-verbally giving one another? How well are they in tune with one another and what needs to change so that she can support her partner better? What questions could you ask either of them to support them in working together to resolve his needs?
Step 5 – what have you learnt
Ask yourself what learning’s you can take from this and what they would enable you to tell yourself to do that would be more supportive for your partners. How are you coming across to him and what do you need to change.
On reflection many may argue that not every man is experiencing an identity crisis and generation by generation there will be fewer men that will be able to identify with the traditional roles of our parents. Equally, many men are embracing this new ear of emotional openness and equality between genders with all of their vigour and enthusiasm.
However, whether your partner is in despair with his identity or simply experiencing the emotional turmoil of a much more competitive, global and demanding life, you will be able to revisit and enjoy the benefits that both of these approaches can bring to a lasting relationship.
Author - J. Keightley (PGcert Coach, Cert Prac NLP)
Published in New Woman magazine 07/2007
Psychologist Liz Wray from the Walking Coach gives an eye opening interview to